Beauty is subjective — or so they say. I put that theory to the test on Blind Ranking Online's Most Attractive Women category, and the community had some strong opinions. I walked away with a 73 out of 100 — a solid "Good Effort!" — but a few of my picks raised some serious eyebrows compared to what 84+ other players ranked.

Here's a full breakdown of where I agreed with the crowd, where I was a little off, and where I completely diverged.

My Rankings vs The Community

Where I Was Spot On 🎯

Sabrina Carpenter – #1 (Perfect Match)

This was my one and only perfect score — and honestly, I'm not surprised. Sabrina Carpenter has been everywhere lately and her appeal is undeniable. Pop star, style icon, and undeniably stunning — the community agreed without hesitation. We both put her at #1. This was the easiest call on the entire list.

Where I Was Close 👍

Emilia Clarke – #2 (±1 Off)

I ranked Emilia Clarke at #2. The community placed her just one spot away. Khaleesi herself — this one tracks. Her charisma and striking features clearly resonate broadly. Barely a whisker of difference between my take and the crowd's.

Bella Hadid – #3 (±1 Off)

Bella Hadid at #3 felt natural to me. One of the most famous supermodels in the world, she's widely regarded as a once-in-a-generation beauty. The community basically agreed — just one rank off. Safe, defensible, and almost consensus.

P!nk – #9 (±1 Off)

P!nk near the bottom of my list — not a dig at her, just a reflection of how stacked this category was. The community landed almost exactly where I did. We both see her as someone who belongs in this conversation but not near the top given the competition here.

Where I Drifted a Bit 🤔

Meghan Trainor – #4 (±3 Off)

I put Meghan Trainor at #4 — this is where things started diverging. The community ranked her noticeably lower (or higher, depending on direction). She's charming and likeable, but the community apparently sees her differently in a straight attractiveness ranking. Three spots is significant — this was the first real gap.

Mariah Carey – #5 (±3 Off)

Mariah Carey is a timeless icon and I rated her accordingly — #5. But the community moved her three spots in one direction. There's likely an age-of-peak-beauty debate here — are people ranking current Mariah or prime Mariah? I went with legendary status. The community was more grounded in the present.

Aishwarya Rai – #6 (±3 Off)

Aishwarya Rai is arguably the most universally acclaimed beauty on this entire list — former Miss World, Bollywood royalty, and someone who tops "most beautiful women" lists globally. I put her at #6 which, looking back, might be too conservative. Three spots off suggests the community was more generous with her placement than I was. This might be my biggest oversight.

Rosé (BLACKPINK) – #8 (±3 Off)

I had Rosé at #8. The community disagreed by three positions. K-pop fans have always been vocal about BLACKPINK's visuals, and Rosé in particular has a massive following. The gap here might simply reflect the global K-pop fanbase pushing her higher in community rankings than my placement reflected.

Where I Was Way Off ❌

Angelina Jolie – #7 (±5 Off — Biggest Gap)

This is my biggest miss of the entire game. Angelina Jolie at #7? The community disagreed by a whopping 5 positions. Angelina Jolie is arguably the most iconic beauty of her generation — Academy Award winner, humanitarian, and the face of "Hollywood glamour" for decades. The community clearly sees her much higher than I placed her. I underestimated the Jolie effect. Big mistake.

Kaia Gerber – #10 (±4 Off)

Kaia Gerber landed at the bottom of my list — #10. The community moved her up 4 spots. As the daughter of Cindy Crawford and a successful model in her own right, Kaia carries elite genetics. The community clearly thinks she deserves far more credit than I gave her. Putting her last was probably too harsh given who she is and what she represents in the modeling world.

Final Verdict: 73/100 – "Good Effort!"

A score of 73 out of 100 means I was in the right neighborhood but not always picking the same house as the community. My wins came at the top of the list — Sabrina Carpenter spot on, Emilia Clarke and Bella Hadid nearly perfect. The cracks showed in the middle and bottom, particularly with Angelina Jolie (way too low) and Kaia Gerber (also too low).

The biggest takeaway? The community trends toward ranking timeless, globally recognized names higher — Angelina Jolie and Aishwarya Rai being prime examples. Meanwhile, my list skewed toward more current pop culture relevance, which is why Sabrina Carpenter felt like an obvious #1 to me.

Beauty really is in the eye of the beholder — but 84+ players can't all be wrong. I'll give Angelina the respect she deserves next time.

Want to test your own rankings? Play the Most Attractive Women blind ranking now and see how your taste compares to the community.